What’s behind the new uproar
A new YouTube Shorts clip circulating among drivers alleges some California Highway Patrol (CHP) officers are “afraid” to perform Level I inspections and are letting non‑English‑speaking truck drivers go. The timing of the claim matters: since June 25, 2025, English language proficiency has been elevated to a driver out‑of‑service (OOS) violation under the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance’s (CVSA) criteria, intensifying scrutiny of roadside interactions between inspectors and drivers.
What a Level I inspection actually includes
CVSA’s North American Standard Level I inspection is the most comprehensive roadside exam. It combines a full driver check (CDL, medical card, hours-of-service, etc.) with an under‑vehicle mechanical inspection covering brakes, steering, suspension, tires, wheels, lighting, cargo securement and more. By contrast, a Level II is a walk‑around inspection without the inspector going under the vehicle, and Level III focuses on driver credentials only.
Why inspectors sometimes select Level II instead
Enforcement leaders emphasize that choosing the inspection level depends on safety and location. A Level I requires an officer to be beneath or beside a truck in live traffic; if conditions aren’t safe—such as a narrow shoulder on a busy freeway—inspectors may shift to a Level II or III and reserve Level I for safer controlled areas like a scale house or inspection bay. That decision is about scene safety, not “fear” of doing Level I.
The English-proficiency rule—what changed in 2025
Federal law has long required CMV drivers to “read and speak the English language sufficiently to converse with the general public, understand highway signs and signals, respond to official inquiries, and make entries on reports and records” (49 CFR §391.11(b)(2)). In 2025, CVSA added English proficiency non‑compliance to its OOS Criteria, meaning drivers who cannot meet the standard during an inspection may be ordered out of service. The update followed FMCSA enforcement guidance issued this year.
California is under the microscope
The policy shift has become a flashpoint in California. In mid‑October, federal officials said they would withhold roughly $40 million from the state over alleged failures to enforce the English‑proficiency standard—part of a broader pressure campaign to tighten compliance. California countered that its safety record and enforcement mechanisms comply with federal law.
Associated Press reporting also highlighted data points underpinning the dispute, including a federal claim that since the June 25 change, only 1 out of 34,000 California inspections resulted in a driver being placed OOS for English deficiencies, and that some drivers flagged elsewhere continued driving after inspections in California. State officials argue they follow the rules; the clash underscores how roadside discretion and state procedures are being reevaluated under the new regime.
What this means for owner-operators and fleets
- Plan for the inspection level to fit the location. Expect more Level I inspections at scale houses and controlled sites; roadside shoulders may still see Level II/III for safety reasons. Train drivers to cooperate and ask where a safe inspection can occur if traffic conditions are hazardous.
- Reinforce English proficiency. Review 49 CFR §391.11(b)(2) with drivers and ensure they can converse with officers, understand signs, and complete inspection documents. Consider targeted coaching for common inspection questions and signage.
- Anticipate stricter OOS exposure. Since June 25, inability to demonstrate English proficiency may lead to an immediate OOS order and operational delays. Build contingency plans for swaps or recovery if a driver is sidelined.
- Tighten pre‑trip routines. Level I inspections are comprehensive; consistent pre‑trip and brake system checks reduce defects that can escalate a walk‑around into a full Level I.
- Monitor California enforcement signals. With federal funding in play, expect increased attention on roadside outcomes and documentation. Keep inspection paperwork tidy and ensure drivers know where to find it quickly.
Bottom line: the viral clip taps into real driver concerns, but inspection level choices are largely governed by safety and setting. Meanwhile, the English‑proficiency rule now carries OOS consequences nationwide—and California’s enforcement is being closely watched. Equip drivers for clear communication, keep equipment tight, and expect more scrutiny where conditions allow safe Level I inspections.
Sources Consulted: CVSA, FMCSA, Associated Press, Reuters, Commercial Carrier Journal.
Need to file your Form 2290?
Join thousands of owner-operators and carriers who trust HeavyTax.com for fast and easy HVUT e-filing.
This article was prepared exclusively for truckstopinsider.com. For professional tax advice, consult a qualified professional.
