A federal watchdog has opened a review of how the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is handling English-language proficiency requirements for commercial drivers — a move that lands amid a sharp, real-time escalation in enforcement activity on U.S. roads, according to the primary report from FreightWaves.
Fresh enforcement tallies help explain the urgency. As of September 17, 2025, roadside inspections have led to 3,020 out-of-service orders tied to English Language Proficiency violations since late June, according to federal inspection data compiled this week by industry outlet CDLLife. The Western region accounts for the largest share (1,141), followed by the Southern (878), Midwestern (615) and Eastern (386) regions. Those counts roughly doubled the mid-August figure, signaling that inspectors and carriers are rapidly adjusting to the reanimated standard.
A separate snapshot published on September 17 put the year-to-date pace of violations near 10,000 — with the 3,020 out-of-service orders representing the subset that resulted in immediate shutdowns — underscoring that the rule is no longer a paperwork-only problem but a capacity and compliance issue fleets must actively manage.
Why it matters to carriers and drivers: the watchdog review dovetails with a shift that makes English proficiency a practical gatekeeper at the roadside. An out-of-service order for failing the English standard appears on a driver’s record, can weigh on a carrier’s safety profile and insurance costs, and strands equipment and freight until a qualified operator can be dispatched. Even if your fleet isn’t directly targeted, the risk shows up as dwell time, recovery costs and schedule misses.
Operationally, the recent surge in out-of-service actions suggests three immediate priorities for motor carriers. First, pre-screen for English capability as rigorously as you do for hours-of-service and medical card compliance; the scale of September’s numbers shows the screen is now live at the roadside, not just at licensing. Second, document “reasonable assurance” that your dispatch, safety and driver training programs enable drivers to understand instructions and signage — particularly for night operations and detours where dynamic message boards are common. Third, build a recovery playbook: when a driver is benched during an inspection, have a protocol to swap operators, secure the load and file any appropriate challenges through DataQs if facts support it.
For shippers and brokers, the trend line carries pricing and service implications. A higher rate of roadside removals typically tightens available capacity at the margins and introduces schedule variance, especially in regions showing the heaviest enforcement. Procurement teams should expect more pointed questions from carriers about appointment windows and detention, and they may see carriers favor lanes that minimize exposure to frequent inspection corridors while the enforcement wave plays through. The week-over-week growth in out-of-service counts suggests those adjustments are already underway.
The watchdog’s inquiry — focused on FMCSA’s oversight of English testing and how the standard is being applied — will likely probe consistency. Enforcement uniformity across regions is a perennial pressure point in trucking; the latest data show regional skews that invite questions about training, criteria and due process. Carriers should expect auditors and state partners to examine whether assessments are documented to a defensible standard and whether drivers have a clear path to return to service after remediation — an area where uneven practices can compound safety and labor-market friction.
Bottom line: This is no longer a theoretical regulation. The inspection window has moved from the CDL counter to the shoulder, with measurable effects on safety scores and service reliability. Fleets that front-load language screening and coaching — and that can prove it — will be best positioned if the watchdog’s findings push FMCSA toward even tighter, more uniform enforcement in the weeks ahead.
Sources: FreightWaves, CDLLife, Carscoops
This article was prepared exclusively for TruckStopInsider.com. Republishing is permitted only with proper credit and a link back to the original source.
