What happened — and why it matters

A viral post on r/Ask_Lawyers describes a driver who briefly worked for a 1099 trucking company in 2025, never got paid for one load, and now — in early 2026 — received a Form 1099‑NEC showing $9,500 in “income” even though only $2,636 ever hit their bank. For owner-operators and fleet managers, this is more than a headache: incorrect information returns can trigger IRS mismatch notices and distract you from running freight. The good news is there’s a paper trail and a process to fix it — if you act methodically and document everything.

First, understand what the 1099-NEC is (and isn’t)

Form 1099‑NEC reports nonemployee compensation paid to contractors. It is not a promise to pay, and it’s not the same as W‑2 “wages.” If the amount reported to the IRS doesn’t match what you actually received, you don’t have to pay tax on money you never got — but you do need to file correctly and explain the discrepancy to avoid automated underreporting notices. The IRS Schedule C instructions explicitly say that if totals on Forms 1099‑NEC exceed what you report as gross receipts on Line 1, you should attach a statement explaining the difference. Keep that language in mind as your north star.

Your step-by-step playbook

Reconstruct the truth. Pull settlement statements, rate confirmations, proof of delivery (POD/BOL), fuel advances, chargebacks, factoring remits, and bank deposits for the period in question. Create a one-page reconciliation showing “1099‑NEC reported” versus “cash actually received.”
Ask for a corrected 1099‑NEC. Email the payer’s accounting contact with your reconciliation and request a corrected form. Be professional, give a deadline, and keep all correspondence. If you can’t get a corrected form, you can still file accurately — see the next steps.
File an accurate return, then attach an explanation. Report your actual gross receipts on Schedule C Line 1. If the payer’s 1099‑NEC total is higher than what you report, attach a brief statement: identify the payer, the 1099‑NEC amount, the amount you actually received, and why (for example, “unpaid load; disputed deductions”). This aligns with the IRS’s own instruction to attach an explanation when 1099‑NEC totals exceed Line 1.
Expect and respond to a mismatch notice if it comes. If the IRS later issues a CP2000-style notice, respond with your documentation and the same reconciliation. Staying consistent with the explanation you attached usually resolves it.
Document the nonpayment with regulators if needed. If the dispute stems from a broker that didn’t pay, file a complaint in FMCSA’s National Consumer Complaint Database (NCCDB). While FMCSA won’t adjudicate individual invoices, complaints help flag patterns and can trigger enforcement attention.

If a broker owes you for a load

When the nonpayment involves a property broker, you may be able to pursue the broker’s $75,000 financial security (bond or trust). FMCSA’s oversight is designed to ensure brokers maintain that security; the agency has emphasized its role is compliance oversight rather than mediating specific bond claims, so you’ll work directly with the surety/trust provider using your documentation (rate con, clean BOL/POD, invoice, and demand letters). Filing an NCCDB complaint alongside your recovery efforts helps build a record.

If a carrier or 1099-leasing company shorted you

For disputes with a motor carrier you contracted with (not a broker), this is typically a contract collection issue. Your evidence package is the same: rate con, proof of delivery, settlement, and payment terms. Many drivers start with a formal demand letter and, for smaller amounts, use small-claims court in the carrier’s home state. Regardless of the recovery route, keep the tax issue separate: file based on cash actually received and attach that explanatory statement to head off IRS matching problems.

Preventive moves for fleets and O/Os

Match settlements to information returns monthly. Run a monthly audit so that the year-end 1099‑NEC equals net payments actually made, not gross numbers distorted by unreconciled advances or chargebacks.
Set a correction protocol. Designate a contact and a 10‑business‑day SLA for investigating and issuing corrected 1099‑NECs when contractors raise discrepancies.
Attach statements proactively. If you’re the payee and a correction won’t arrive by filing time, don’t wait — file accurately and include the explanation the IRS asks for.
Use the NCCDB when appropriate. If a broker pattern emerges, file complaints to put it on FMCSA’s radar while you pursue payment.

Bottom line: you owe tax on what you actually received, not on amounts a company reported in error. File clean, explain the variance in writing, and press your payment claim on a separate track with the right documentation and, when applicable, the broker’s financial security.

This article provides general information for owner-operators and fleet managers and is not tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.

Sources Consulted: Reddit (r/Ask_Lawyers); Internal Revenue Service; Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration.

Need to file your Form 2290?

Join thousands of owner-operators and carriers who trust HeavyTax.com for fast and easy HVUT e-filing.

This article was prepared exclusively for truckstopinsider.com. For professional tax advice, consult a qualified professional.